Alternatives to timesheets

Share on LinkedIn
Share on Twitter
Share on Facebook

Advertising is a deadline-driven world where the efficient management of time is not just beneficial;  its essential for success. Despite this, it’s surprising to find that numerous advertising agencies still navigate their day-to-day operations without a formal time-tracking system. 

This absence, often overlooked, can silently erode an agency’s efficiency, profit margins, and client relationships. 

While timesheets are one of the most common tools used to track time, the creative industry has been reluctant to embrace them. So we are presenting innovative alternatives to revolutionize time management in advertising agencies. 

The Timesheet Dilemma

Traditionally, timesheets have been the cornerstone of tracking time in various industries, including advertising. They require employees to log the time spent on each project or task. This method, in theory, promises precision and accountability but often falters in practice, especially in creative environments.

Let’s explore why timesheets, though valuable, encounter resistance:

Timesheets are perceived as tedious

 Many creatives view timesheets as mundane administrative tasks that detract from their creative flow.

Time-Consuming Nature

The act of filling out timesheets is often seen as a chore that eats into productive work time.

Retrospective Innaccuracy

Timesheets often filled out at the end of the day or week, can suffer from recall bias, leading to inaccuracies

Flexibility Constraints

In a field where inspiration strikes unpredictably, rigid time tracking can seem like a creativity killer. 

The Impact of Poor Time Management

The repercussions of inadequate time tracking are more severe than they appear at first glance. Here’s what happens when an advertising agency doesn’t track time effectively:

Billing Discrepancies

Without accurate time records, agencies struggle to bill clients correctly, leading to potential revenue loss or disputes.

Resource Misallocation

Inaccurate tracking results in poor project and resource planning, often leading to staff burnout or missed deadlines.

Profit Margin Squeeze

Underestimating project costs due to poor time tracking directly affects an agency’s profitability.

Alternaties to track time

While timesheets have long been the default method for tracking time in the advertising industry, they are far from the only option available. Nowadays there are innovative approaches that range from task-based models, where employees focus on completing specific tasks within a set timeframe, to more holistic methods like profit and loss (P&L) based approaches, which consider the broader financial picture of the agency.

Each of these alternatives offers its own set of advantages, addressing the unique challenges that timesheets present, and opening up new ways to conceptualize and manage the valuable resource of time in the creative industry.

Task-Based Approach

Under this approach, employees are given a set of tasks with defined deadlines. Completion of these tasks marks the end of their work commitment, allowing them to engage in additional activities.

Pros: Encourages efficiency and rapid completion of tasks.  Accurate task estimation aligns with business objectives and employee incentives 

Cons: The agency must ensure tasks are economically viable and cover employee costs and overheads. 

Implementation: For this method to work effectively, tasks must be clearly defined, achievable, and aligned with overall business goals. This approach also requires a robust system to track task completion and measure its impact on business performance. 

Charged Tasks

This method evolves the task-based approach by financially incentivizing each task completed, over a base salary. 

Pros: It’s particularly beneficial for smaller agencies with variable workloads. It directly aligns employee earnings with productivity. 

Cons: This model might not be well-received in all markets and can be challenging for creatives who prefer stable income. 

An Agency in Poland successfully implemented this model balancing basic salary with task-based incentives, leading to increased productivity and employee engagement in business development. 

Resource Plan-Based Management:

With this method, a resource planner assigns employees to projects for specific durations, focusing on task completion within these timeframes. 

Pros: Encourages focused work and efficient use of time based on historical data and experience. 

Cons: Risks of time underestimation, leading to overwork and employee dissatisfaction

Tip: To mitigate risks, agencies must have contingency plans and regular check-ins to adjust workloads and timelines. 

Profit & Loss (P&L) Based Approach:

This macro-level approach to tracking time focuses on covering the agency’s cost base through sales and project delivery. 

Pros: Effective for agencies with steady work streams like retainer contracts or fixed-price projects. 

Cons: Still requires careful project time estimation, particularly when involving freelancers or external resources. 

Tip: Agencies must develop robust forecasting models and maintain a keen eye on market trends to ensure the cost base is consistently covered and profit margins are maintained. 

In Conclusion

The advertising world, with its blend of creativity and commerce, requires time management strategies that are both flexible and effective. Moving beyond traditional timesheets to more innovative methods can lead to improved efficiency, heightened employee morale, and enhanced profitability.

Agencies willing to adopt these alternative approaches may find themselves better equipped to navigate the complexities of the modern advertising landscape, delivering value to clients while fostering a dynamic and productive work environment.

Get tips to manage your agency in your inbox

Subscribe to our blog

Would your agency survive a recession?

Find out if your agency is ready to meet the challenges of the future- and overcome them

You seem to want to improve your agency

Let us help by sending tips straight to your inbox

tips to manage agencies