Agencies struggle to estimate profitable projects

The agency ‘holy grail’ – profitably estimating projects

Share on LinkedIn
Share on Twitter
Share on Facebook

The landscape for agencies is rapidly changing, facing one of their biggest hurdles yet: profitably estimating projects. Today, agencies grapple with clients who expect more for less, marking a significant shift away from the once-reliable Time & Materials and retainer models.

Understanding the Estimation Struggle

Agencies are finding it increasingly difficult to estimate projects profitably. This struggle often stems from underestimating the scope or complexity of projects, leading to reduced profit margins and, in some cases, burnout among employees.

When a project is underestimated, it can strain resources, damage client relationships, and ultimately affect the bottom line.

The struggle of estimating projects is multifaceted, rooted in both the dynamic nature of client demands and internal operational complexities.

Evolving Client Expectations:

Clients today often expect more comprehensive services at lower costs. This shift in expectations can lead to agencies underestimating the scope and resources required for projects, as they attempt to meet these demands while staying competitive.

Complexity of Projects

Modern projects are becoming increasingly complex and multifaceted. Agencies must deal with a myriad of variables, from rapidly changing technology to diverse client needs. This complexity makes it harder to accurately estimate time, resources, and costs.

Resource Allocation and Burnout

Incorrectly estimating projects can lead to misallocation of resources. Overcommitting the team on underquoted projects can result in employee burnout, decreased productivity, and lower-quality outputs. This not only affects the current project but can also have long-term impacts on employee morale and retention.

Balancing Quality and Cost:

Agencies strive to maintain a high standard of work while managing costs effectively. Underestimating projects can force a compromise between quality and profitability. Delivering quality work within a tight budget and timeline requires precise and realistic project estimation.

Market Competition and Pricing Pressure

Advertising is an intensely competitive market in which agencies often feel pressured to lower estimates to win projects. This can lead to a cycle of underbidding, where the true cost of a project is not accurately reflected in the estimate, impacting profit margins.

Risk Assessment and Contingency Planning

Agencies often struggle with assessing risks and including contingencies in their estimates. Unexpected issues, such as scope creep, client revisions, or unforeseen market changes, can derail a project’s budget and timeline.

Lack of Historical Data and Benchmarking

The lack of historical data on similar projects can make estimating challenging. Benchmarking against past projects helps in creating more accurate estimates, but this requires having a detailed and organized record-keeping system.

Communication Gaps

Miscommunication or lack of clear understanding between the agency and client regarding project objectives, deliverables, and expectations can lead to inaccurate estimates. Ensuring that all parties have a mutual understanding is crucial in developing an effective estimate.

Addressing the struggle

To address the struggles around estimating projects, agencies need a comprehensive approach that involves training teams on estimation techniques, investing in project management tools, improving client communication, and developing a culture that values accuracy and transparency in project estimation.

By acknowledging and strategically addressing these challenges, agencies can improve their estimation processes, leading to more sustainable operations and profitable outcomes.

There are other strategies that agencies can implement to profitably estimate projects. 

Strategies for estimating projects profitably

To estimate a project profitably, the first thing you need to do is get clarity on the project type. Different projects- be it fixed fee, retainer or Time & Material require distinct estimation approaches. 

Implementing specific strategies can significantly improve the accuracy and profitability of project estimates:

Implement a Phased Estimation Approach

Break down the project into smaller phases or milestones. Estimate each phase separately to manage complexity and allow for adjustments as the project progresses. This approach can accommodate changes without significantly impacting the overall estimate.

Leverage Historical Data and Analytics

Use data from past projects to inform current estimates. Analyze completed projects to understand actual versus estimated costs and time. This historical data can provide insights into common pitfalls and areas where estimates tend to deviate from reality. 

Adopt a System to Track Time

Implement a robust time-tracking system to gain a clear understanding of how much time tasks actually take. This data helps in making more accurate future estimates and identifying areas where efficiency can be improved.

Utilize Estimation Software

Invest in specialized estimation software that can help in creating detailed and accurate estimates. These tools often include features for risk assessment, scenario analysis, and cost calculations, making the estimation process more reliable and less prone to human error.

A tool like WorkBook (designed & built by agency veterans for ad agencies) allows agencies to create templates for any type of job (including retainers). This allows agencies to effectively estimate each type of work.

Involve Multidisciplinary Teams in the Estimation Process

Include team members from different disciplines (creative, technical, managerial) in the estimation process. This collaborative approach ensures that all aspects of the project are considered, leading to more comprehensive and accurate estimates.

Regularly Review and Update Estimates

Treat estimates as dynamic, not static. Regularly review and adjust them as the project progresses and more information becomes available. This adaptive approach can help in managing unexpected changes and keeping the project on track.

Clearly Define Scope and Manage Scope Creep

Establish a clear and detailed project scope before beginning the estimation process. Implement strong scope management practices to avoid scope creep, which can significantly impact project costs and timelines.

Develop Contingency Plans

Include a contingency budget in your estimates to account for unforeseen circumstances. Typically, a contingency of 10-20% can provide a buffer against unexpected costs or delays.

Practice Transparent Client Communication

Engage in open and honest communication with clients about costs, timelines, and potential risks. Setting realistic expectations from the outset can prevent misunderstandings and scope changes later on.

Offer Tiered Pricing Options

Present clients with multiple pricing options based on different scopes or service levels. This not only provides clients with flexibility but also allows agencies to manage resources more effectively based on the chosen option.

Emphasize Value-Based Pricing

Where possible, move away from purely time-based pricing to value-based pricing. Charge based on the value or results the project delivers to the client, rather than just the time spent. This approach can align client expectations with agency efforts and encourage efficiency.

Conduct Post-Project Reviews

After project completion, conduct a review to compare the initial estimate with the actual project outcome. Analyze discrepancies to understand where the estimation process can be improved for future projects.

In Conclusion

The key for agencies in this competitive market lies in having the right tools and processes. Adapting to the changing demands of project estimation requires flexibility, clear communication, and a deep understanding of both market trends and client expectations. By employing diverse and tailored strategies, agencies can navigate these challenges and maintain profitability in their projects.

Get tips to manage your agency in your inbox

Subscribe to our blog

Would your agency survive a recession?

Find out if your agency is ready to meet the challenges of the future- and overcome them

You seem to want to improve your agency

Let us help by sending tips straight to your inbox

tips to manage agencies